• Thanks for visiting The Penturners Forum today.

    There are many features and resources that currently you are unable to see or access, either because you're not yet registered, or if you're already registered, because you're not logged in.

    To gain full access to the forum, please log in or register now. Registration is completely free, it only takes a few seconds, and you can join our well established community of like-minded pen makers.

Nicholas Andrews

Full Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2018
Posts
12
Location
North Yorkshire
First Name
Nicholas
I appreciate this has been discussed many times before but there is currently an interesting dialogue on The International Association of Penturners members forum about pen finishing. I take this to be a concern with wood rather than acrylics as using one of the proprietary polishes on plastic materials seems to last a very long time in my experience. As the IAP forum suggests, the natural oils and acids in our own bodies will eventually affect the finish on pens whatever method of finishing is used. CA glue will probably hold out longer than most but might not be liked because it may have an artificial appearance. At least one pen maker who sell as a business states clearly pens have a wax polish. Using e.g. a hard wax oil in satin or gloss , which I prefer for most of my bowl work, gives a lovely finish which seems to be troubled less by body acids but does, of course, take several days and many coats to apply properly.
I would appreciate hearing from members with their own experiences about how long finishes on wooden pens last. And if we sell them should we be advising purchasers the finish is likely to change within a relatively short time of usage? Do we advise re-polishing? and, if so, with what product?
 

silver

General dogsbody
Executive Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2013
Posts
6,301
Location
Somewhere in Staffordshire,
First Name
Eamonn.
Interesting points and yes been seems to have been discussed since BC.

I don’t use Polish as in my personal experience no matter what you use I have never had any success. I know that [MENTION=2403]TVS[/MENTION] has had some good experiences with a polish. Which I’m sure will come on and explain at some point.


I use Melamine Lacquer as a finish, great success and it’s great fully received by my customers. Who are the best ones to take advice from.
 

TVS

Fellow
Joined
Nov 21, 2021
Posts
1,157
Location
Notts
First Name
Woody
Not getting involved last time I got called a lier but I make and turn a lot of pens and sell them as quick as I can make them to returning customers all of my wood pens have a polish finish and have had for many years and that’s good enough for me in answer to the original question yes with any pen ou need to explained aftercare as indeed you do with any item you make
 

flexi

Executive Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2014
Posts
6,159
Location
Maidstone
First Name
mark
I have used CA and it can be very durable but takes away the wood feel and warmth (its also difficult to apply and you should have good ventilation). Personally I use Melamine laquer which isn't as thick so gives a more pleasent feel to the wood, it's easier to apply although it should be allowed 24hrs to fully harden. I also use Truoil on my walnut blanks and have a gunstock finish to them, again very durable and easily applied, but takes time to dry.
I have also tried a polyurethane varnish with a dipping method, an oil finish which has shellac and various other ingredients in but whilst quick and easy isn't as durable.
I think for as long as I have been turning, this has been debated even friction polish has been used with a microcrystalline wax top coat.......
I will continue to experiment, but stick with my 2 main styles at the moment, melamine and Truoil...... If a customer asks what to refinish a pen with, I usually say its good for a few years depending on usage, either return it to me for free or wipe microcrystalline wax on. I have only had one come back in 10+years but it had been through a washing machine
 

Garno

Fellow
Joined
May 12, 2021
Posts
1,372
Location
Dronfield
First Name
Gary
Being new to pen turning I seem to struggle no matter what I do but have found 2 or 3 coats of CA seems to work best for me whilst still keeping the wood feel.
Not everyone will agree with that and no doubt I will be asking again and again. I do like melamine though if used sparingly.
I like the idea of wax as well,
 

pittswood

Fellow
Joined
Mar 14, 2016
Posts
1,251
Location
Rhigos, South Wales
First Name
Kelvin
I have not used CA glue for some time now. Most of the pens I make now (Rhondda Tunnel Society, their Teak wood rail blocks), are wood sealed and two coats of Chestnut wood wax 22, polished between each coat. I know that different woods are better with some other wood finishes. I have been experimenting over the last years with different wood finishes on numerus woods and I have found a happy medium in my finishes.
Kelvin
 

alan morrison

Fellow
Joined
Feb 26, 2019
Posts
2,379
Location
Co. Down N Ireland
First Name
Alan
I use a couple of different finishes.
Abranet to 600, buff with Tripoli, then White Diamond and finish with Carnauba wax.
sometimes Melamine Lacquer a la Phil Dart.
 

Geoff Kent

Graduate Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2021
Posts
496
Location
Westcliff on Sea,Essex.
First Name
GEOFF
Melamine as per Phil Dart.I believe all finishes will eventually wear off if the pen is regularly used,to be replaced by a natural patina.Take a look at a well used wooden item,you will see what I mean.A lovely,aged,shine.
 

AllenN

Fellow
Joined
May 20, 2013
Posts
2,242
Location
Lancaster, UK
First Name
Allen
I use melamine and I also include a note explaining that pens are meant to used and any wear on the pens caused by prolonged use should be looked on as a sign of affection. A touch of microcrystalline wax can add a bit of sparkle but I point out that is really just a cosmetic effect.
 

Penpal

Grand Master
Joined
May 26, 2013
Posts
25,340
Location
Canberra AUSTRALIA
First Name
Peter
I have used CA and it can be very durable but takes away the wood feel and warmth (its also difficult to apply and you should have good ventilation). Personally I use Melamine laquer which isn't as thick so gives a more pleasent feel to the wood, it's easier to apply although it should be allowed 24hrs to fully harden. I also use Truoil on my walnut blanks and have a gunstock finish to them, again very durable and easily applied, but takes time to dry.
I have also tried a polyurethane varnish with a dipping method, an oil finish which has shellac and various other ingredients in but whilst quick and easy isn't as durable.
I think for as long as I have been turning, this has been debated even friction polish has been used with a microcrystalline wax top coat.......
I will continue to experiment, but stick with my 2 main styles at the moment, melamine and Truoil...... If a customer asks what to refinish a pen with, I usually say its good for a few years depending on usage, either return it to me for free or wipe microcrystalline wax on. I have only had one come back in 10+years but it had been through a washing machine

Loved True Oil but it dries up in the container too fast for mine making it expensive.
 
Warning! This thread has not had any replies for over a year. You are welcome to post a reply here, but it might be better to start a new thread (and maybe include a link to this one if you need to).
Top